How We Rank Products
At Bestonomy, we’ve developed the SmartScore — a data-driven ranking algorithm that blends expert reviews, real customer feedback, popularity trends, and more to surface the best products for your pet.
Expert Review Mentions (30%)
We scan expert review websites and rank products higher when they show up in multiple trusted “best of” lists.
Average Customer Rating (20%)
We analyze ratings across Amazon, Walmart, Chewy, and normalize across platforms for consistency.
Ratings Trend (15%)
We track whether a product’s ratings are improving or declining over time.
Popularity Metrics (10%)
We look at search interest, social buzz, and best-seller rankings to measure demand.
Review Volume (10%)
More verified reviews = more trustworthy data. We reward well-tested products.
Availability & Price (10%)
Products that are in stock and fairly priced rank higher.
Special Mentions & Awards (5%)
Extra points for certifications, design awards, and vet or trainer endorsements.
SmartScore Breakdown
| Factor | Weight |
|---|---|
| Expert Review Mentions | 30% |
| Average Customer Rating | 20% |
| Ratings Trend | 15% |
| Popularity Metrics | 10% |
| Review Volume | 10% |
| Availability & Price | 10% |
| Special Mentions & Awards | 5% |
Why You Can Trust Our Rankings
We don’t accept sponsored placements. We update our rankings frequently. And we only recommend products we’d give to our own dogs.
Real reviews. Real data. Real results.